The Desert War: Gaming WW2 In North Africa Part Four – Turning The Tide

September 7, 2015 by crew

For the past three weeks, we have reviewed (and more importantly, gamed) our way through some of the more decisive engagements of the Desert War, fought primarily in the deserts of North Africa during World War II. For those just joining us, our progress thus far has been presented in Parts One, Two, and Three of the series.

But, after two years of ebb and flow, attack and counter-attack, a crisis point has been reached in the late summer of 1942. Having been thrown back halfway across Egypt, the Allies can retreat no further. Having exhausted their supplies and reinforcements, the Axis can wait no longer. The Allies are out of space, the Axis is out of time. One way or another, a decision will now be made at a tiny desert railroad town…called El Alamein.

Map Of Africa

A Decisive Push

As we saw in Part Three, “Panzergruppe Afrika” decisively defeated the British and their Commonwealth allies at the Battle of Gazala. Rommel was thus able to overrun Tobruk (which had held out for 240+ days the last time the Germans had been here), and push the Allies back into Egypt. The British attempted to make a stand at Mersa Metruh, but were outflanked and defeated again. This time the retreat took them all the way back to El Alamein.

In direct violation of orders, Rommel went after them. His superiors knew this was a bad idea, to push this deep into Egypt against numerically superior forces would badly overstretch his already-vulnerable supply lines. The British knew it, too, and were using every weapon they had to strike at these supply routes.

Long Ranged Desert Group

One of these weapons was the Long Ranged Desert Group (LRDG), which was about to carry out their most famous raid …

The Long Range Desert Group

“Operation Caravan” was an LRDG strike at the Axis airfield at Barce, on the northern coast of Libya. It was part of a larger series of commando-type operations aimed at disrupting Panzerarmee Afrika’s lines of communication and supply, involving the SAS, British Commandos, the Royal Marines, the Royal Navy, and even a battalion of line infantry.

Battlefield

Interestingly, the Italians largely defeated all of these operations except Operation Caravan. The operation is also unusual because the LRDG was usually deployed as a reconnaissance force rather than a “commando strike” unit. Experts in desert navigation and survival, they often took the SAS to their targets, rather than strike the targets themselves. But, as they certainly showed at Barce, the LDRG could “get messy” with the best of them.

Checkpoint

Ironically, the LRDG’s attack on Barce was not a complete surprise as they’d been spotted some time ago by the Italian Air Force. However, the Italians at the airfield did not expect the attack to come straight off the main road, “through the front door,” especially since one of their own columns had just passed up that same road. These Italians and the LRDG actually passed each other in the night, going so far as to wave hello. Such was the “fog of war” in the desert, especially in darkness.

Defensive Position

The raid was a success, with just four of the LRDG attackers wounded. Accounts vary on how much damage they did, ranging from between 16 and 32 aircraft destroyed. Four LRDG vehicles had been wrecked and so many of the men had to WALK across the desert to other LRDG rendezvous points. They were attacked from the air and harried by Italian counter-attacks, while some LRDG raiders were captured.

This just goes to show that, despite the movies, “special forces” are just as fragile as any other troops. As units, they’re even more fragile because of their small size and lack of heavy weapons support.

Long Range Strike

These operations are complex and dangerous, and as we’ve seen as recently as Pakistan in 2011, it doesn’t take much for something to go awry…especially with your ride home. Who can forget that crashed helicopter at Bin Laden’s compound?

Turning Point At Alamein

Back at the Alamein Line, meanwhile, the Eighth Army was trying to pull itself together after the twin disasters of Gazala and Mersa Metruh. Now set up at the superb defensive position at El Alamein, they knew there could be no further retreats. Alexandria was just ninety miles behind them, with Cairo, the Nile, and the Suez Canal beyond.

Fortunately, things finally started to turn around for the Allies. In early July, Rommel hit them yet again in a series of attacks, and with the Qattara Depression blocking his favourite “hook around the south” strategy, he had to wrack his brain. Rommel had come to the end of his leash. Generals Auchinleck and Ritchie hit back, heavily mauling Panzerarmee Afrika but not failing to push them back. This “First Battle of El Alamein” is largely considered a draw.

Plan Of Attack

Meanwhile, Winston Churchill came to Egypt to have a look around for himself. Despite the recent checking of Rommel at the First Battle of El Alamein, Churchill yet again switched out his commanders. Auchinleck was rather unfairly replaced as C-in-C Middle East by Harold Alexander, while Ritchie was replaced as Eight Army commander by General Gott.

Gott, however, was shot down by two Messerschmitt Bf-109 fighters, then strafed and killed as he tried to help others out of the wreckage. Next in line, almost by mischance, just happened to be a bloke named Bernard Law Montgomery. History would never be the same.

Battlefield Plan

While Montgomery undoubtedly inherited a great defensive position and reinforced Eighth Army from Auchinleck, “Monty” also went about restoring his army’s cohesion and espirit de corps. After all, this army had been under six commanders in two years, constantly reorganized, and pummelled repeatedly by an army one-third its size. This army needed to find its confidence, and through hard training and discipline, Monty gave them exactly that.

Meanwhile, the exhausted, ill-supplied, and terribly exposed Panzerarmee Afrika tried one last time to break Eighth Army’s line at the Battle of Alam Halfa. Again the Germans were defeated, further strengthening Eight Army’s resolve. Furthermore, a massive new convoy had just arrived from England, and the British took delivery of hundreds of their new “wonder weapon,” the American Sherman tank.

Tanks Roll In

Another of Montgomery’s better traits was that he would not be pushed around by Churchill. All through the Desert War Churchill had pressured British generals into premature attacks that came to predictable disaster (then Churchill would fire the hapless commander). Monty would have none of it. Despite incessant pressure, he meticulously trained, reorganized, and reorganized his Eighth Army. He would attack only when he, and they, were ready.

Thus, when Eighth Army finally hit Panzerarmee Afrika on October 23, 1942, it did so with the force of a thunderbolt. The artillery barrage was horrific, some sources claim it was the biggest single barrage since 1918. But the Germans and Italians both held out. After all, just as the Alamein battlefield had been a great defensive position for the Allies, so it was for Panzerarmee Afrika now that the positions were reversed.

Dust On The Horizon

Behind this massive artillery barrage, British and Allied infantry delicately cleared lanes in the sprawling minefields (the operation was ironically code-named “Lightfoot”), through which British armour was intended to strike. It didn’t work at first. Axis minefields were too deep, Italian infantry were too stubborn (especially in the south), and German 88s were just too accurate. After four days, however, the Allies steadily bent and eventually cracked the Axis line in the north.

Frantic to contain this threat, Rommel hurled his three heaviest divisions (15th Panzer, 21st Panzer, and Italian “Littorio” Armoured) into a pincer assault on the flank of the Allied salient, which was anchored on a very modest “hill” called Kidney Ridge. Both sides knew what defeat would mean here, and accordingly the battle at Kidney Ridge was savage, desperate, heroic, and extremely bloody.

Close Up

In the end, Kidney Ridge held. The Allied drive into Rommel’s northern wing was secure, and Panzerarmee Afrika had expended the very last of its strength. Montgomery reorganized and hit the Axis again with “Operation Supercharge,” which finally shattered enemy defences.

Utterly broken, the Germans finally had to break off and begin a retreat all the way out of Egypt, all the way across Libya, and eventually all the way to the Tunisian border. So starved was the Axis for fuel that Rommel could only evacuate his German units, tens of thousands of Italians were simply abandoned to be captured by the Allies. The tide had turned, this time for good. The mythical aura of the “Afrika Korps” and the “Desert Fox” were forever shattered.

As Winston Churchill remarked: “No, this is not the end. This is not even the beginning of the end. But it is, perhaps…the end of the beginning.”

Smoking Wreckage

Even worse for Rommel, entirely new Allied forces had landed behind his forces in Tunisia. These, of course, were the “Operation Torch” landings in the French colonies of Morocco and Algeria. Now the remnants of Panzerarmee Afrika would face not only British and Commonwealth forces, but for the first time, American forces as well.

Of course, the Germans would also be getting help. New units, new generals, and new tanks would all be pouring in, turning “Panzerarmee Afrika” into “Army Group Afrika.” Come back next week as this restored and recovered Axis force meets its new enemies for the final, climactic showdown in the Desert War.

James Johnson

If you would like to write an article for Beasts of War then please contact me at ben@beastsofwar.com for more information!

"Next in line, almost by mischance, just happened to be a bloke named Bernard Law Montgomery. History would never be the same..."

"The artillery barrage was horrific, some sources claim it was the biggest single barrage since 1918..."