Reply To: Hobby weekender 17/05/19 – A good tone, tone deaf, dark tone? AtmosFearic!

[limburger 21709xp 0]

@mage there’s never any accounting for taste 😉
I liked the first one, because it managed to be in sync with the book and it had that bit of wimsy (dwarves singing) that the book calls for.

The second one wasn’t bad, but it suffered from being the middle in a trilogy and the pacing felt off.
The less said about the 3rd or the flockin’ love scenes with the elf the better. The absolute worst part is Smaugs’ death as the first scene …

I think this would have been best as a tv-series with each chapter/adventure getting one or two episodes.

Please do tell us about Coriolis.

Some music to finish off :

And a bit of Springsteen, except not as you know it :