Scythe

Community

8.3

19 Ratings

Your Rating

Log in to rate

Rate Game Silver or Gold Stars (Click Twice for Gold & Again to Unrate)

Playability

Components

Writing

Art Direction

Replayability

Supported by (Turn Off)

Review: Scythe - superb world creation and immersion

August 16, 2018 by zoidpinhead

In Love

Supported by (Turn Off)

Step into a steampunk alternative 1920 where a mysterious factory run by genius Nicola Tesla has fallen silent and the envious eyes of world powers contest its ownership and dominance of Europe and the world.  This superb 4X game has so much going for it.  It is written by Jamey Stegmaier of Stonemaier Games and benefits from his keen understanding of how to use different game mechanics to drive a superb gameplay experience with a host of replayability potential.  The artwork by Jacob Rozalski is superb and was what initially drew me to the game.  He has created a thoroughly believable world within which to game and the experience of gaming in his universe is soon to be available on PC as Scythe meets Dawn of War in Iron Harverst.  In the meantime Scythe is a terrific alternative.  The game requires a play or two to get a full understanding of the mechanics and then you are away.  Whilst I feel it is better as a four player game I’ve played with more and less and always had a good time.  There is also a solo version using a card mechanic to drive the opponent.  It is a superb setting and has so much to offer the wargamer looking for opportunities to game in the gaps.

Leave a Reply

8 Comments on "Scythe – superb world creation and immersion"

torros
Member
7805xp

Possibly in 40 odd years of gaming this was the most boring and uninteresting game I have ever played

tankkommander
Member
1326xp

Agreed. It is a dull multiplayer solo. The theme is great, the game is not.

lukeabberley
Member
113xp

A game as beautiful as it is boring. It pretends to be about dynamic movement, narrative, and player interaction but in reality these are pointless, rather secondary, considerations to isolated engine building and turtling.

tankkommander
Member
1326xp

Boring game with a great theme. Dull ‘engine building’ that never gets going, just feels like people sat around a table playing their own game rather than with/against each other. The theme is wasted on this dull euro that steals from a lot of other games. I have no idea why it is so highly rated.

torros
Member
7805xp

I would agree.There is zero interaction between the players

angelicdespot
Member
2237xp

Ha ha, wow – seems like not everyone agrees!

I’m a convert. I didn’t back the Kickstarter as the game looked dull. It had amazing art, but it didn’t look as though the game captured the excitement of it.

So I suppose that when I played the game, I wasn’t really expecting much. But I really enjoyed it – enough to then go and buy myself a copy.

It’s not a fast game and I suppose I get that some people feel like there’s player interaction missing. But I really liked the ‘base-building’. I really liked the feeling of being in control, having a plan and seeing it gradually build up. I liked that it appears complex but actually runs very simply – giving you lots to think about and take into account, but giving you the tools to keep an eye on everything.

lancorz
Admin
3488xp

Agreed, over the past few days we’ve been playing this at my home and we’ve fallen in love. I realise that it may not be as competitive as others but I love working up to an end goal and chasing down that last goal before your opponent, we’ve had bets over the tables and discussions on how to manipulate others into taking other’s land.

I disagree that the game isn’t interactive with your opponents. The game can be very social and interactive depending on the group you play with.

lukeabberley
Member
113xp

That can be said for any game.