Reply To: LotR revisited – what Peter Jackson got right and what he didn't

[grantinvanman 9615xp 0]

Ironically, Tom Bombadil in TROP is VERY good. Probably one of the most fun characters, absolutely as he brings out the character of Gandalf and helps him find the perfect stick.

I would have liked to have seen the barrow wights on film, as well as the Scouring, and I could have done without the elves magically and robotically showing up at Helm’s Deep – which was literally for me the most cringeworthy of all the movie scenes. It was almost as bad as all of the The Hobbit trilogy – which is nearly unwatchable.