Reply To: LotR revisited – what Peter Jackson got right and what he didn't

[pagan8th 14710xp 0]

I think Liv Tyler was good as Arwen. She always seemed to tall and thin to me to be a human. In Armageddon looked ‘gangly’!

Elrond seemed to stern. Galadriel didn’t look elven really.

Often in films they portray the wise and elderly as being slow speaking and that just makes them seem slow witted.

Although the films are different from the books, the spirit of them is there and I do like them. Watched them all several times.

I don’t have prime, but I’ve heard little good said about that variant of middle earth.