Reply To: frostgrave vs ghost archipelago what's better?

[osbad 4279xp 0]

Both systems are good, so really it boils down to a personal aesthetic choice.

Our group having played both generally preferred Frostgrave.  In our general opinion it felt that Frostgrave better represented how we imagined it felt to be a wizard, who needed to shield himself with minions but had some powerful spells, than it represented a “superhero” with minions.  In our opinion, the protagonists always felt a bit too vulnerable to truly represent how the fluff represented them and how we wanted to play them “leading from the front” in the game.

However it was still fun, and the rules and models worked fine.